I now realize why Law & Order episodes last for only an hour. If they were to actually last the length of a normal complete trial, the viewing audience would be mentally exhausted from all the minutia. That's exactly how I felt after my first stint ever on a jury.
The trial started at 9am on Thursday and didn't end until 5pm on Friday. As we filed into a much smaller courtroom than I had imagined, we were assigned seats based on our juror number. I was number 5, the only male in a 12-member panel. First the judge talked for about 30 minutes on what to expect (zzzzzzzzz). Both lawyers then had their chance for opening statements (nowhere NEAR as compelling as My Cousin Vinny).
To summarize the offense, a cop pulled up behind a car that was double-parked with its flashers on in a mostly-black neighborhood. The car had 2 white guys and a black guy in it, so that threw up a red flag to the cop. They cited the driver for a traffic violation, the white guy in the back seat was charged with having an open container and marijuana. The black guy in the front passenger's seat, who was in a skull-bolted halo that restricted his movement, was charged with marijuana possession and paraphernalia possession, cocaine possession and paraphernalia possession, and intent to distritbute cocaine. Our job was to decide the guilt or innocence of the black guy (FYI, not only were 11 out of 12 jurors female, all of us were white- not exactly a jury of his peers).
The defense attorney said his client conceded having the marijuana and related paraphernalia. They vehemently contested the other three charges relating to the cocaine possession. This was what we needed to examine. The defense claimed that the backseat passenger slipped three "8-balls" (marbled-sized bags of coke) into the left pocket of the defendent's oversized parka. The halo he was wearing prevented him from turning his head down or left at all, and the harness made of hard plastic extended down to his wasted. His 8-inch parka pocket was already open and flap tucked in. Three cell phones were already weighing down this pocket. The backseat passenger testified under oath in his own trial that he put the cocaine into the defendent's pocket because, being under probation, he didn't want to go back to jail, and he didn't think the police would search a guy in a halo.
When the defendent was taken out of the car and patted down, the cocaine was discovered, along with the three cell phones, marijuana blunts, and about $1500 in cash in his pants pockets. He also had a cell phone-sized digital scale in his upper coat pocket (typically used to measure finite amounts of powders or herbs). The defendent owned up to everything in his possession, but was "completely shocked" as the cocaine was laid out on the hood of the car.
Ok, now it's your turn to play the juror. How would you vote? I'll save the result til the end.
Since the defended openly admitted his guilt with respect to the two marijuana charges (#4 & #5 on our list), we quickly took a formal vote on those and moved on. We first deliberated on the cocaine paraphrenalia (the scale). In order to say he's guilty of that charge, we have to be convinced that the scale was used specifically for the cocaine found in his pocket. State police ran tests on the scale and found no traces of narcotics on it. For whatever reason, they ran no other tests on it. Still, to move on to the major offenses, we conceded that the scale could have been used to measure that cocaine. Perhaps he was going to buy it from the backseat passenger eventually, had the police not intervened. So there it was, guilty on count #3, possession of paraphernalia relating to cocaine.
Now, let's deal with count #1- possession of cocaine with intent to distribute. This charge was filed because there were three bags and not just one, the thought being nobody buys three bags of coke just for themself, I guess. At first vote, there were only 4 people that thought him not guilty of that charge, myself included. Here was my issue: what proof were we given that he INTENTED to distribute the cocaine? If it was his cocaine, and if he was going to sell it to the two guys in the car, why didn't he already? They were in the car together for almost an hour driving around and parking. The prosecution said that he must have already sold alot of it since he had all the cash in his pocket. The defense provided a copy of a cashed workman's compensation check for $2400 from a month earlier. We finally came to an agreement that, although he might have eventually, the prosecutor failed to provide any evidence to make that charge stick. Not guilty on count #1.
Finally, after 4 1/2 hours of sitting in very uncomfortable chairs in a narrow room (I think that's the point, actually, get in and get out as fast as you can), we were down to only one charge- possession of cocaine. Here is what the judge specifically stated: "possession must meet two criteria- the power or ability to control, AND the knowledge to control". That means that if you're carrying a gun in your purse but you didn't know it was there, that's not possession. So what we had to decide was, did the defendent know the cocaine was in his pocket? Keep in mind, we must decide this beyond a reasonable doubt. Again, the initial vote was 8-4 in favor of guilty. I had two basic arguements against his guilt on this charge. Given the backseat passenger's testimony at his own trial, is it POSSIBLE that he did slip the three 8-balls (which together weighed about 10.5 grams) into the open jacket pocket of an oversized parka worn by a guy that couldn't move his head or neck? I thought so. After making that point, the vote turned to about 9-3 in favor of not guilty. The next thing I asked, which I think stuck with most people, was this. If he is a drug dealer, and he knows he's got all this coke on him, why didn't he dump it? The officer that testified even said that most drug dealers and buyers will throw it in the grass, drop it or otherwise just try to get it off of them. The defendent had all the time the cop was sitting in his car behind the incident car (about 3 minutes), he had time while a second officer was carefully helping him out of the car. He could have put it in the car's console, glove box, inside the seat, under the seat or simply on the floor. He didn't do any of that. He didn't even make any attempt to cover up that pocket that was hanging wide open. Wouldn't that be the natural instinct if you knew you had that junk in your pocket- get rid of it or at least cover it up? He did neither. The three ladies that still thought guilty were still using the three cell phones and $1500 cash as mitigating evidence of his guilt. However, he was not being charged with possession of phones or possession of cash. The question was were we certain, beyond a reasonable doubt, that he knowingly possessed the cocaine. Final vote- not guilty.
After almost 6 hours of deliberations, we had reached unanimous decisions on all 5 counts. I'm not sure when his sentencing hearing is, but I will be looking for the results in the newspaper. Nobody felt great about their decision, as drugs in our communities touch sensitive nerves on all of us. We are comfortable in knowing that we applied the letter of the law as best we could. We felt that had the commonwealth used a better or more experienced prosecutor (this guy seemed like it was his first case), the outcome may have been different. There were just so many unanswered (an even unasked) questions that could have made this case more of a slam dunk for the commonwealth. That just wasn't the case.
Overall, it was a unique experience of which I was thankful I could be a part. It opened my eyes to how different TV court is from real court. Few things in my life have ever been as stressful as the near six hours in that jury room. Although we were calm and respectful at all times, the fact that you hold someone's freedom in your collective hands was a heavy burden we held. It's something that I don't look forward to doing again anytime soon.
Saturday, August 22, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment